Eli > Peyton ?

[Deleted User]

PimpMVP wrote: »

The same Eli that folds under a slight hint of pressure.

The same Eli that'll go into a slump if he makes a mistake?

That Eli?

u mistaking Eli for his big brother right now ........

Already Home_17

Mrslim1 wrote: »

The thread title has a question mark . But I raised the question because at this point its debatable on who would you want in big games . The 2007 Patriots and the 2011 Packers if they had won a title would have been looked at as some of the best teams in the history of the NFL . Eli ( and the D of course ) ended all that shit . Peyton just comes up short at times in Big spots

besides the superbowl run and this season, so did eli

sdotcarter111

Peyton is the Lebron of quarterbacks. Eli is the DWade.

its....JOHN B

PimpMVP wrote: »

So Eli having a better defense his whole career than Peyton means nothing?

colts defense is the reason peyton has a ring, 3 tds 7 int in his superbowl run, thats awful, and lets not talk about all the big games he choked in before that year, peyton is obviously better all time consistently putting up numbers and putting his team in a position to win, but if you ask me who i would want starting in a big game its eli, he excels in big games

R.D.

sdotcarter111 wrote: »

Peyton is the Lebron of quarterbacks. Eli is the DWade.

peyton got a ring...comparison not valid or even close to being accurate

ClemsonKUjayhawks215

Peyton has been choking since he was tennessee...its funny how tennessee won the BCS the YEAR AFTER peyton went to the nfl.....I guess Tennessee didnt have a defense either...when are we gonna stop making excuses for peyton?

Darius

ClemsonKUjayhawks215 wrote: »

Peyton has been choking since he was tennessee...its funny how tennessee won the BCS the YEAR AFTER peyton went to the nfl.....I guess Tennessee didnt have a defense either...when are we gonna stop making excuses for peyton?

whats even funnier is the clemson football defense giving up more points than their basketball defense

ClemsonKUjayhawks215

Matt- wrote: »

whats even funnier is the clemson football defense giving up more points than their basketball defense

whas even funnier is having 24,000 post on here smh

Darius

ClemsonKUjayhawks215 wrote: »

whas even funnier is having 24,000 post on here smh

whats even funnier is a college football team giving up 70 points

EmM HoLLa.

You niggaz funny... Lol... I'm glad u finally respect my quarterback... Redemption is sweet.. Niggaz was a SB MVP n niggaz was shittin on him like he was a scrub... Smh... Go back to doubting I like being the underdog much better...

FlyFreeCt

EmM HoLLa. wrote: »

You niggaz funny... Lol... I'm glad u finally respect my quarterback... Redemption is sweet.. Niggaz was a SB MVP n niggaz was shittin on him like he was a scrub... Smh... Go back to doubting I like being the underdog much better...

My point exactly...Good to see my QB gettin love, but it makes me sick at the same time cuz niggas is flip floppin now...and as soon as he has a bad game niggas gon' be back on that same bullshit.

ClemsonKUjayhawks215

Matt- wrote: »

whats even funnier is a college football team giving up 70 points

stop dog u making ya self look like a real nut....anyway point is eli is better

vageneral08

Mvpbrodie93 wrote: »

He choked.

Eli
Brady
Big Ben
Joe montana
Peyton
For example have all had a chance to either WIN or LOSE the Superbowl in the 4th quarter.

Peyton throws the interception to lose it

Nigga you must've forgot he was down by 7 anyway so even if they would've scored it would've been just tied up and it would be on the defense to make a stop.....

ocelot

Yall niggas keep disrespecting the GOAT

I'm sppose to be #1 on errbody list... Let's see what happens when I no longer exist... fuck this shit

KillaCham

Its gonna be interesting to see how Eli develops after this year, and even moreso how he stacks against Peyton when he comes back. Good to see him having pretty much his best year yet and shutting his detractors the fuck up.

As for the thread, in the clutch I gotta go with ELIte.

numbaz...80's baby

ImParallel wrote: »

Its shaping up to be that Eli may retire better than Peyton...right now if both stopped playing I'd still go Peyton, he's the best regular season QB I've seen in my life (tied in SB wins).

I think Eli can surpass him with another SB win and a couple more solid regular seasons though (which seems very doable nh). I don't see Peyton getting another SB ring unless he gets cut/traded and ends up on a real contender somehow...wouldn't be surprised if he's playing in an indoor wheelchair league somewhere soon either tbh.

This.........

Mvpbrodie93

vageneral08 wrote: »

Nigga you must've forgot he was down by 7 anyway so even if they would've scored it would've been just tied up and it would be on the defense to make a stop.....

He still choked.


Like Always

Mvpbrodie93

its....JOHN B wrote: »

colts defense is the reason peyton has a ring, 3 tds 7 int in his superbowl run, thats awful, and lets not talk about all the big games he choked in before that year, peyton is obviously better all time consistently putting up numbers and putting his team in a position to win, but if you ask me who i would want starting in a big game its eli, he excels in big games

Exactly. During his 07' SB run
97 of 153 (63.4%) for 1,034 yards, 6.8 YPA, 3 TD, 7 INT, 70.5 passer rating*

Terrible, especially the first 2 games. Lowest QB rating For a SB winning QB during his playoff run ever(yes lower then Trent Dilfer)

Eli got more TD's NOW then Peyton did that ENTIRE run

bankrupt baller

i guess a teams D means nothing these days....smh.

David Ruffin

Wait.....so Brady isn't better than peyton BUT eli is?

R.D.

The fact that this thread made it this far shows the drop off in quality posts from the cheap seats

It used to be a lot more balanced but the idiots far outnumber sensible posters in here'

Justin Sane wrote: »

Wait.....so Brady isn't better than peyton BUT eli is?

apparently, Eli is an all time great all of a sudden

bankrupt baller

the media brain washed these fucking sheep when they started calling him "elite manning".......

vageneral08

Mvpbrodie93 wrote: »

Exactly. During his 07' SB run
97 of 153 (63.4%) for 1,034 yards, 6.8 YPA, 3 TD, 7 INT, 70.5 passer rating*

Terrible, especially the first 2 games. Lowest QB rating For a SB winning QB during his playoff run ever(yes lower then Trent Dilfer)

Eli got more TD's NOW then Peyton did that ENTIRE run

big ben owns that title back in 05

Mvpbrodie93

vageneral08 wrote: »

big ben owns that title back in 05

For the SB, not the Whole playoffs


That's Peyton.

Big Ben 05' Run
58 of 93 (62.3%) 803 8.63 YPA
*7 TD'S 3*Picks 101.7 Passer Rating

Peyton 07 Run


97 of 153 (63.4%) for 1,034 yards, 6.8 YPA, 3 TD, 7 INT, 70.5 passer rating*

FlyFreeCt

I'm the biggest Eli fan in this bitch, but niggas is disrespecting Peyton right now...Eli is a damn good QB (on the cusp of greatness with 2 more wins) but he's not Peyton....Like I said he's better in the clutch but he's not the QB Peyton is......Having said that though, I still wouldn't want any other QB leading my squad than Eli, he constantly makes plays and it's been this way for a while and has been ignored...and to think he didn't make that bullshit top 100 NFL players list Lmao!!! That shit is laughable when you look at some of the names that are on there instead of Eli...5th best QB in the league hands down...If your quarterback ain't Brady, Peyton, Rodgers or Brees, fuck you...