More Deserving of Comeback Player of the Year: P. Manning or A. Peterson?

Already Home_17

i seen an argument on first take about which one of these two deserve MVP more. since i felt its too early to decide, but comeback player of the year will definitely come down to these two

Peyton Manning: missed all of last season due to 4 procedures on his neck, released by the colts after 14 seasons, arm strength in question, ability to take hits were questionable, the team he chose to sign to raised eyebrows especially since teams like the 49ers were interested in him

season stats:
Yards: 2,705
TDs: 21
Int: 6

team record: 6-2

Adrian Peterson: tore his ACL and MCL late last season. people questioned whether he should start the first week of this season, even if his game would ever be the same

season stats:
carries: 195
Yards: 1,128
YPC: 5.8
TDs: 7

team record: 6-4

Already Home_17

my fault at the peyton manning option being there twice. i couldnt post without there being a third option for some reason

BDB

Adrian Peterson

I would give it to AP.

lamontbdc

Dam they gonna have to share this award for real

playmaker88

Toss up honestly... they both encounter great risk for the positions they play and the specific natures of their injuries...they both get a salute

northside7

Adrian Peterson

AP.

Torn ACL & MCL and has a chance to finish as the top rusher..

KeepOnPushing

Adrian Peterson

Ryan Fitzpatrick , the fact the Bills let this man Comeback is amazing

Matt-

Peyton Manning

Manning. just for the fact that his injury was a bit more career threatening. especially at his age

but both have come back as good as they ever were. so it will be tough. Manning could very well end up being the league MVP, and as dumb as it is, they probably wouldn't award him with mvp and comeback player.

Michael_Malice

Adrian Peterson

AD= Comeback Player of the Year

Manning = MVP

ocelot

Adrian Peterson

Somehow I expected Peyton to be Peyton... I thought AP would be doing this next season

greenwood1921

Adrian Peterson

Might as well give it to AP. Manning got MVP sewed up unless his neck tighten up again.

representingda203

Adrian Peterson

ap got that sewed up and lol at peyton getting mvp

Shizlansky

Peyton Manning

If Manning wins MVP he should get Comeback player.

Will Munny

Adrian Peterson

AD

R.D.

toss up

coop9889

representingda203 wrote: »

ap got that sewed up and lol at peyton getting mvp

Why wouldnt Peyton get mvp

blackjack2012

Peyton Manning

They was talking about manning maybe never playing again and now he's a frontrunner for the mvp

numbaz...80's baby

Honestly you couldn't go wrong with either one.

MikeydaGawd

imo who ever wins it is whoever gets to the playoffs.

J. Will

Adrian Peterson

All fucking Day...Peyton can go a game without gettin touched if his o-line is on point...AD HAS to get touched, he's banging and burning off on niggas like he never got hurt

R.D.

^Peyton career couldve been over though

personally, i think they should split it

LysolJenkins

Peyton Manning

Shizlansky wrote: »

If Manning wins MVP he should get Comeback player.

boom

smittysmith

AP Da GOAT

#1hiphopjunki3

Adrian Peterson

J. Will wrote: »

All fucking Day...Peyton can go a game without gettin touched if his o-line is on point...AD HAS to get touched, he's banging and burning off on niggas like he never got hurt

What Peyton had to endure deserves props no doubt but I agree with JWill 100% about the fact that running backs take way more abuse than any other offensive skill position player and everybody and there momma knows that the Vikings are gonna run the rock and Peterson has been amazing

So ILL

Smittysmith, who is that girl in your sig? That ass is bouncing back like Mystikal lol...


I'd give the award to Peterson. Dude came back from his injury like he never left and is putting in work. I saw somewhere that dude has like 600 yards rushing in the last 3 games which is crazy.

#1hiphopjunki3

Adrian Peterson

Why is nobody talking about Matt Ryan for MVP so far? I mean they have one of the best records in the NFL and he is playing great