The Official RG3 vs Luck Debate

KingGivBiz

merged

KingGivBiz

RG3

Who you got Cheap Seaters?

fightforolddc

RG3

Man I dunno. I hope RG3 but i think both will be great.

KingGivBiz

RG3

fightforolddc wrote: »

Man I dunno. I hope RG3 but i think both will be great.

I think both will be great too, but who will be BETTER?

bow to royalty

Don't watch college ball so my opinion doesn't mean too much. But from what I've heard about each QB...Luck. Pocket QB's with running ability>>Running QB's with some passing ability. But like I said I haven't seen em. Could be underestimating RG III's passing.

fightforolddc

RG3

bow to royalty wrote: »

Don't watch college ball so my opinion doesn't mean too much. But from what I've heard about each QB...Luck. Pocket QB's with running ability>>Running QB's with some passing ability. But like I said I haven't seen em. Could be underestimating RG III's passing.

Yes you are. Griffin is a pocket passer who just happens to have trackstar speed.

Usually when QBs get drafted, you have to assess their weaknesses against their strengths. What weakness do either quarterbacks have?? You have to nitpick to find weaknesses with either. I guess you could say Griffin isn't tall at only 6'2, but that's reaching. What weakness does Andrew Luck have? I don't see a single one.

Matt-

Depends on where each gets drafted

greenwood1921

Griffin will be the better one. Luck will be another Drew Bledsoe at best (which ain't shabby, but nowhere near what the media makes him out to be.)

If history is any indicator, one will be a bust and the other a Canton candidate.

KingGivBiz

RG3

fightforolddc wrote: »

bow to royalty wrote: »

Don't watch college ball so my opinion doesn't mean too much. But from what I've heard about each QB...Luck. Pocket QB's with running ability>>Running QB's with some passing ability. But like I said I haven't seen em. Could be underestimating RG III's passing.

Yes you are. Griffin is a pocket passer who just happens to have trackstar speed.

Usually when QBs get drafted, you have to assess their weaknesses against their strengths. What weakness do either quarterbacks have?? You have to nitpick to find weaknesses with either. I guess you could say Griffin isn't tall at only 6'2, but that's reaching. What weakness does Andrew Luck have? I don't see a single one.

Drew Brees is 6'1' so... btw, RG3 is a pocket passer who happens to be fast and black, so he oftens gets mislabeled.

greenwood1921

fightforolddc wrote:

bow to royalty wrote: »

Don't watch college ball so my opinion doesn't mean too much. But from what I've heard about each QB...Luck. Pocket QB's with running ability>>Running QB's with some passing ability. But like I said I haven't seen em. Could be underestimating RG III's passing.

Yes you are. Griffin is a pocket passer who just happens to have trackstar speed.

Usually when QBs get drafted, you have to assess their weaknesses against their strengths. What weakness do either quarterbacks have?? You have to nitpick to find weaknesses with either. I guess you could say Griffin isn't tall at only 6'2, but that's reaching. What weakness does Andrew Luck have? I don't see a single one.

Luck's weakness is that he gets rattled fairly easily, and I've seen him stare receivers down. Puts too much air under some of his passes sometimes (same with RGIII).

bow to royalty

Guess it's wait and see. And it probably will come down to what their franchises do with them. Redskins may be willing to spend tons on offense to help RG3, and Colts may be willing to keep drafting offensive weapons like they did for Peyton.

BDB

RG3

I think RG3 will be better but Luck is gonna be real good also. IMO worst case scenario for Luck is Matt Schaub level. This is all barring injuries of course.

Matt-

And I think Griffin could be an elite qb. But with all qbs that can run, injury is always a concern. He doesn't have the build of cam or Tebow.. Not to say he can't take the beating, but I'd like to see how he responds to NFL players hitting him. Of course the same can be said for luck, but RG will undeniably take on more tackles

greenwood1921

Got the feeling durability may be an issue for both. Both have gimpy knees on the low.

Luck coming into the league rockin the same double knee-braces that Dan Marino was rockin in his last few seasons. lol.
And RG blew his knee out a couple years ago.

Shizlansky

One will be great and one will be average. Only time will tell.

BlackAX410

Aint even gon front Im hopin RG3 is WAY betta the Luck due to all the hype Luck got (best QB prospect since Elway, replacing Peyton Manning, calls his own plays, safest pick in the draft, coulda went ahead of cam last year) Luck is under the microscope nd he betta produce immediately

lamontbdc

toss up. I think RG3 is going to the better team though.

DaBull

Rg3

usmarin3

I don't know if RG3 will reach his full potential with Shannahan as his head coach. Dude seems like the type of coach who can wear down a young QB or won't allow him to go through the process of messing up.

FroHawke

RG3

RG3, his game is special. I feel Luck was more a system guy, everything safe, no risky throws...ultra efficient though. If RG3 can take the hits, he'll be a great one.

Co-Town Michael

RG3..
And for the record, I've NEVER EVER been impressed by any throw Andrew Luck made or characteristic he has ever displayed.
Dude is overrated as fuck.

d.green

RG3.

I think Luck was hyped out more than he should've with the media.

He's good and all but i dont see anything that really stands out.

RG3 has an arm, speed, clutch gene, etc. He just looks better on film. He took Baylor places they had never been without a Jim Harbaugh on the sideline.

#1 pick

Both will be damn good. I want to say Griff but I also want to say Luck but at the end I'll say Griff but Luck has a better organization.

greenwood1921

Co-Town Michael wrote:

RG3..
And for the record, I've NEVER EVER been impressed by any throw Andrew Luck made or characteristic he has ever displayed.
Dude is overrated as fuck.

Co-sign. Left hand and all.

KNiGHTS

usmarin3 wrote: »

I don't know if RG3 will reach his full potential with Shannahan as his head coach. Dude seems like the type of coach who can wear down a young QB or won't allow him to go through the process of messing up.

This is the wild card right here. Luck is under the media microscope. No one in Indy is going to second guess anything he does because they want him to succeed. Shannahan is a fucking douchebag control freak who'll hurt the whole team to prove he's in charge instead of letting a player play his way. RG3 will constantly end up trying to be molded.

It could work or it could destroy him. All I know is the Donovan situation gives me zero faith it'll be positive in Washington.

icecoldstew

RG3

KNiGHTS wrote: »

This is the wild card right here. Luck is under the media microscope. No one in Indy is going to second guess anything he does because they want him to succeed. Shannahan is a fucking douchebag control freak who'll hurt the whole team to prove he's in charge instead of letting a player play his way. RG3 will constantly end up trying to be molded.

It could work or it could destroy him. All I know is the Donovan situation gives me zero faith it'll be positive in Washington.

lmao and why is that?


RG3 will have the quicker impact for the simple fact that he's going to be on a better team. Not sure who will have the better career but I think they both will be good to great QB's