So we gonna act like Peyton didnt have another chance to win a playoff game

245

Replies

  • its....JOHN Bits....JOHN B Posts: 9,613 ✭✭✭✭✭
    I just believe its an accomplishment within itself to be in that many playoffs games. I do believe that players, fans & the media gives him too much credit like naming him a top 100 player without even playing last season. With that being said, I still feel that his success and the way he changed the game cant go unnoticed.

    No doubt, I still got him top 10 arguably top 5 so i'm not gonna hate, but anyone that puts him in Brady, Montana and Elways class is senseless, same people that say Peyton is one of the goats probably got Favre top 5 too, blinded by the media
    numbaz...80's baby
  • ClemsonKUjayhawks215ClemsonKUjayhawks215 Posts: 316 ✭✭✭
    I just believe its an accomplishment within itself to be in that many playoffs games. I do believe that players, fans & the media gives him too much credit like naming him a top 100 player without even playing last season. With that being said, I still feel that his success and the way he changed the game cant go unnoticed.

    No doubt, I still got him top 10 arguably top 5 so i'm not gonna hate, but anyone that puts him in Brady, Montana and Elways class is senseless, same people that say Peyton is one of the goats probably got Favre top 5 too, blinded by the media

    I can respect that

  • ShizlanskyShizlansky Nothing better then being a father. Posts: 18,689 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Why is Montana better then Manning?

    Why is Brady better then Manning?
    When Brady was asked to carry the team he hasn't won a superbowl yet. Matter of fact he loss two.

    How is Elway better then when he 50/50 in superbowls. And when he did win he wasn't carrying the team to them. Cuz he was clearly a shell of himself.

    Manning, Elway, Brady, and Montana is all in the same convo.
  • ClemsonKUjayhawks215ClemsonKUjayhawks215 Posts: 316 ✭✭✭
    Brady is 16-6 in the playoffs....please name the offensive weapons he had that are even comparable to harrison, wayne, edgerrin, and dallas clark??????

    Fucking joe montana is 4-0 in the SUPER BOWL...the nigga NEVER threw a INT in 4 super bowl appearances

    Elway was clutch like a muthafucka..complete opposite of manning
    Already Home_17blakfyahking
  • ShizlanskyShizlansky Nothing better then being a father. Posts: 18,689 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    Disciplined InSightcoop9889almighty breezeblakfyahking
  • vageneral08vageneral08 Fuck how ya feel Posts: 16,582 ✭✭✭✭✭
    where are these unknown niggas coming from?
    Already Home_17
  • ClemsonKUjayhawks215ClemsonKUjayhawks215 Posts: 316 ✭✭✭
    Brady had a 4th qtr comeback against the rams when NOONE in the world gave them a chance to win
  • Cutler 26 INT's LOL!Cutler 26 INT's LOL! Posts: 6,142 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Ima say this...

    Peyton Maninng had more responsibility than any QB in the league and it has been that way for a min. To be 9-11 in the playoffs means you are putting your team in position to win year in and year out. Ya win some ya lose some...

    hueyblakfyahkinginfamous114Already Home_17
  • iKingGodGivBiziKingGodGivBiz Batman With Prep Time Posts: 17,233 Regulator
  • its....JOHN Bits....JOHN B Posts: 9,613 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you
    KNiGHTS
  • its....JOHN Bits....JOHN B Posts: 9,613 ✭✭✭✭✭
    yall give Peyton all this credit for great regular seasons, who had the greatest regular season by a qb ever?
    texasdaking88
  • vageneral08vageneral08 Fuck how ya feel Posts: 16,582 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you

    are you talking about the afc chamionship game? brady got picked off that's what ended the game
  • its....JOHN Bits....JOHN B Posts: 9,613 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you

    can you read
  • vageneral08vageneral08 Fuck how ya feel Posts: 16,582 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you

    can you read

    and how would that made brady have his 4th ring? that game wasnt over then.....how would you know the pats would've beat the bears that year? smh niggas say anything
    coop9889
  • its....JOHN Bits....JOHN B Posts: 9,613 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you

    can you read

    and how would that made brady have his 4th ring? that game wasnt over then.....how would you know the pats would've beat the bears that year? smh niggas say anything

    because Peyton was even able to beat that bum ass team
  • vageneral08vageneral08 Fuck how ya feel Posts: 16,582 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you

    can you read

    and how would that made brady have his 4th ring? that game wasnt over then.....how would you know the pats would've beat the bears that year? smh niggas say anything

    because Peyton was even able to beat that bum ass team

    So because peyton won means brady would've won too? smh that's a dumbass logic
    coop9889almighty breeze
  • Crude_Crude_ Legend Posts: 15,886 ✭✭✭✭✭
    He's a great talent but not a winner.

    He's the Dirk Nowitski of football.
    texasdaking88almighty breeze
  • ClemsonKUjayhawks215ClemsonKUjayhawks215 Posts: 316 ✭✭✭
    where are these unknown niggas coming from?

    lol u sound like a real lame... "who are these unknown niggaz"... nut ass nigga

    ClutchCityCartelits....JOHN Bmiamivice305Figo
  • its....JOHN Bits....JOHN B Posts: 9,613 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shizlansky wrote: »
    Took Elway bout 12 years to win a superbowl.

    Where was his clutchness for over a decade?

    Brady didn't do shit them early years. Tape don't lie, he was average as fuck.

    the year Manning won a superbowl he threw 3 td's to 7 picks and if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would of had a 4th and Manning still wouldnt have one, Brady outperformed him, hes not a big game qb if you just want to talk about numbers than Marino should be mentioned as the goat too, and the fact that you even asked "why is Montana better than Manning?" makes me want to slap you

    can you read

    and how would that made brady have his 4th ring? that game wasnt over then.....how would you know the pats would've beat the bears that year? smh niggas say anything

    because Peyton was even able to beat that bum ass team

    So because peyton won means brady would've won too? smh that's a dumbass logic

    even though i'm 99% sure Pats would of beat the Bears, i'm wrong for assuming so let me correct myself, if Che Caldwell could catch the ball Brady would have "made" it to his 4th superbowl and Manning wouldnt have a ring
  • I Am Jay PeeI Am Jay Pee Posts: 2,075 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Elway played against the NFC east at the height of his dominance with some of the weakest supporting cast around him. Elway had nobody those years he lost
  • I Am Jay PeeI Am Jay Pee Posts: 2,075 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Talent as in what? He has a noodle arm and is unathletic. That is not talent....he is the smartest QB of all time possibly, but sometimes skill and instinct have to take over and that is where he lacks. He can't make plays out of the pocket
    texasdaking88
  • vageneral08vageneral08 Fuck how ya feel Posts: 16,582 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Talent as in what? He has a noodle arm and is unathletic. That is not talent....he is the smartest QB of all time possibly, but sometimes skill and instinct have to take over and that is where he lacks. He can't make plays out of the pocket

    lol noodle arm? you real smart bruh
  • texasdaking88texasdaking88 Posts: 4,778 ✭✭✭✭✭
    Shhhhhhhhhhh..niggas don't like when u bring up ole big head shortcomings yet u will see them say year after year flacco ain't clutch no matter what he does
  • vageneral08vageneral08 Fuck how ya feel Posts: 16,582 ✭✭✭✭✭
    where are these unknown niggas coming from?

    lol u sound like a real lame... "who are these unknown niggaz"... nut ass nigga

    and you sounding real smart making threads like this......how can someon be a choker when they been winning majority of their career? niggas with a 200 post count really think they know shit.....casual ass fan
  • Crude_Crude_ Legend Posts: 15,886 ✭✭✭✭✭
    @I Am Jay Pee

    He is unathletic his arm isn't the best but its far from a noodle arm.

    Other than Aaron Rodgers what other successful QB in the league that has had success is physically talented.

    Eli, Brady, Brees, and Roethlisberger none of them are great athletes the QB position is more about being smart and having pocket awareness just ask players like Michael Vick.
Sign In or Register to comment.