Hell no Mcnabb isn't HOF. I was surprised when I saw the poll results. This dude had 0 4,000 yard seasons. Had 2 years in his career with at least 25 TD's. Career completion % less than 50. Has 1 NFC Championship. Flacco may be closer to HOF than Mcnabb...ya I know what I said
His career completion is 59%, which is good.
John Elway has ONE 4000 yards season (4030) and two seasons with more than 25 TDs too (both only 26). So lets not act like those feats you mentioned means the QB is horrible.
Dashon Goldson is not a champion... How many rings does dude have again?