I think that's just about where he belongs..Kobe was easily the better scorer and defender, but Magic was the better passer, rebounder, and made his team better overall, when you factor in Magic's ability to play all 5 positions on the court I had to give him the edge
Kobe in my book is either 9 or 10 nowhere close to top 5 though. You ranked Kobe over Dream, Larry Legend, Lew Alcidor, and The Big Fundamental? Your top 10 has no Shaq or Wilt Chamberlain? Just doesn't add up in my book.