Luke has been fighting with Namor and Proxima and whatnot lately. He's more in the 70+ ton range now and causes seismic activity with his punches. His durability has ALWAYS been able to handle the likes of Iron Man and Hulk and it still can handle Namor and whatnot.
This isn't close. Luke thunderclaps, smacks Cap once or twice and it's over. Cap would have to literally shield bash him about 25 times just to do something to him. Also Luke's taken on other fast, skilled people like Bullseye and Taskmaster.
Based on? He might be more interesting, but what makes you think he's more physically capable?
Him beating Batman like he stole something. Him constantly whooping the teen titans, the justice league, Flash, etc.
lol Did you just use Deathstroke's wins over Batman as proof that Deathstroke is physically superior to Captain America in a topic where how Cap and Batman compare is being debated? Do I really have to explain the problem with that argument?
Nah but clearly Batman and Cap have similar feats and stats and Deathstroke beating him SO BAD (not just that he won, but it wasn't close really) is a plus for him.
As for your other argument, Spidey did that pretty much once or twice (take teams like that), Deathstroke regularly does it till the point that it's consistent. Teen Titans, Outsiders, Justice League, Flash. At the very least he's much faster than Cap and Batman.